Canadian regulator fines ex-rep $100K for unauthorized trades

A Registered Representative with CIRO and its predecessors since 1979 has accepted a $100,000 penalty and a three-year exclusion from regulatory approval roles after acknowledging unauthorized trades and personal financial arrangements with a client. The agreement, finalized by a Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization hearing panel on November 4, addresses behavior in Montréal, Québec, spanning 2021 to 2022.
The individual, Arthur Silber, was last registered with CIBC World Markets Inc. until June 2023 and is now unregistered in the securities industry. This marks the first disciplinary action taken against him by CIRO or its predecessors.
Between June 2021 and December 2022, Silber issued 13 cheques totaling $4.73 million to a client, identified only as JK, a doctor born in 1950 with an annual income of $250,000 and liquid assets estimated at $4 million. Silber claimed these were loans, but the regulator determined they were meant to offset JK’s losses exceeding $10 million in margin accounts he managed. One cheque for $97,500, dated June 1, 2022, was returned due to insufficient funds.
Silber also executed 1,318 trades in JK’s accounts without explicit authorization, violating rules requiring client approval for discretionary trading. These trades took place between September 2020 and December 2022, with Silber admitting he acted on his own discretion for most. The conduct violated Dealer Member Rule 43 (before January 1, 2022) and Investment Dealer Rule 3100 (afterward) regarding personal financial dealings, as well as Dealer Member Rule 1300.4 and Investment Dealer Rule 3221 for unauthorized trading.
Read Also: iCapital, CAZ Expand Private-Market Access in Canada
Beyond the fine, Silber agreed to a 12-month supervision period if reapproved and to cover $10,000 in costs. The settlement, signed August 11, includes a waiver of further action by CIRO’s Enforcement Staff, provided compliance is maintained. The panel, led by Michel Brunet and including Jacques Lemay and Marie-Julie Nicolo, will publish written findings on CIRO’s website.
Terms of the Settlement and Regulatory Consequences
The agreement labeled the disputed payments as a loan, though the regulator classified them as compensation for losses exceeding $10 million. Silber’s registration with CIBC World Markets spanned January 1990 to June 2023, according to the settlement terms.
The enforcement staff will not pursue further action unless Silber violates the settlement terms, at which point proceedings under Investment Dealer Rule 8200 may follow. The panel’s written reasons for the decision will be posted on the regulator’s website.